Peeled open a late-germinator from ‘New Dawn’ OP and found this white grub instead of an embryo…
What in the PNW do we think it is?
I threw out the rest of the baggie of seeds to be safe.
1 Like
When I was in Chicago last fall I had the opportunity to liberate some OP hips. Some of them had these same looking pests inside the achenes. Most failed but a few managed to sprout and grow while the grub was still eating them. Took me a few days to figure out what was going on, but I managed to save a few where they went for the cotelydons instead of the radicle.
I did the same as you and ditched the seeds since I couldn’t identify the pest. Wasn’t worth the uncertainty.
2 Likes
I like to claim l found the same problem … on R penndulina seeds a couple years ago.
Except not me. Some exceptional observational skills of a sharp expert in Canadain heritage roses spotted the same problem on a photo of my seeds.
Little holes drilled into small seeds. Dump the bag and sure enough dead white grubs with wriggle or two left can out of bag. Cold doesn’t terminate everything on the prairies.
If they see this note they might give you a suggestion what the wriggle rats were- l don’t recall the tech name.
2 Likes
I believe that, in this case, it is a species from the genus Rhagoletis in the family of fruit flies, Tephritidae. I see larvae like this in my rose hips almost every year, and in 2019 I even asked an entomologist I know about it. He confirmed my suspicion. However, the species Rhagoletis alternata (Europe) or Rhagoletis basiola (USA, Canda), rose hip flies, do not eat the seeds inside the hip. These usually continue to develop even when infested.
2 Likes
Crikey that’s a rose defiling monster compared to the little wriggle rat grubs l had that made holes in seeds. Got c if l can find the pictures l took.
From the expert X and AI “
“ megastigamus - a genus of tiny, parasitic wasps (not true flies) within the Chalcidoidea superfamily, often called “seed chalcids” due to their larvae feeding inside plant seeds, particularly conifers and roses”
Could it be the more common larvae of the rose cucurlio?
Always nuking them in my garden when caught in the act of drilling the buds … easy target, bright red here with a wicked looking drill stem - no doubt tip with a diamond studded tri-cone drill bit.
1 Like
I’ve never had this kind of infestation before, but your suggestion fits even better! Interesting and fine that the pest has been identified.
1 Like
I have had a bunch of these in my hips before. They might affect the germ rates some but I still managed to pop some from those batches.
1 Like
Found this old thread (which came up on a google search) and I think we have a match.
1 Like
Looks like a match. Yet another introduced species. Multiflora roses are the gift that keeps on giving.
Those little stinkers are sure a pest! I’ve found they tend to like certain roses, having far more in some than others. They will completely eat a seed up, leaving only an empty shell.
I have, however, kept some seeds after discarding partially eaten ones. The seeds seemed fine and even had some germinate. Of course perhaps there is a risk in keeping some? Perhaps separate them in their own bag?
Duane