Thought I would add one last bit of information on Lillian Gibson. G Buck claimed Lillian Gibson is a Triploid in an article written in 1960.
The following paragraphs are from the American Rose Annual 1960, part of an article by Griffith Buck titled “Progress Report On Breeding Hardy Everblooming Roses”. I copied the it a couple of years ago, from the CyberRose web site I think.
Anyways here’s the section referencing Lilian Gibson. If anyone wants one the whole article I can post it or email it. The complete article also touches on R. blanda, R. laxa of Retzius and R. fedtschenkoana and the difficulties Buck had in breeding directly from species.
"If primary hybrids of a hardy species and garden roses are available,they frequently can provide the means to get around these first generation problems and speed up the breeding program. There were two such hybrids of R. blanda available, Lillian Gibson (R. blanda x Red
Star) and Betty Bland (R. blanda x unknown Hybrid Perpetual). Lillian Gibson combines the plant characters of its parents in approximately equal proportions. The flowers, which are borne in clusters of 10-20, possess good form, good petalage, and clean color. It is a triploid
which produces an abundance of pollen of low viability. Betty Bland shows evidence of its Hybrid Perpetual parent only in the flower which is twice as large as that of the normal blanda flower, doubleness, andin inhibition of the suckering tendency of the species parent. Under
Iowa conditions it produces seed pods which contain few seeds which seldom germinate. Its pollen has good viability. In these progenies the flowers range from single to semi-double in varying lavender-pink tones.
Well-shaped blooms are not common, the principle malformation being a conversion of the pistils to leaf-like organs.
Betty Bland has been a better parent than Lillian Gibson, although it leaves much to be desired. (The progeny vary in hardiness according to their other parent). Excerpts from field notes summarize the Betty Bland-hardy rose variety progenies…"